Table of contents
What Does Catfishing Mean?
According to the eSafety Commissioner, catfishing describes the creation of a fake online identity in order to deceive another person. This is usually achieved via a dating app or social media, but occasionally via communication platforms such as WhatsApp or Telegram.
Perpetrators do it for a variety of reasons, and the impact on victims can be substantial. In many cases, uncovering who is really behind a fake profile requires a deeper look at digital footprints and behaviour patterns, which is where social media investigations can provide useful insights.
While the practice has been around for a long time, the term originates from the 2010 documentary Catfish. It was further popularised by the MTV series by the same name, which premiered in 2012.
Of course, its arrival also coincided with the rise of social media and, in particular, dating apps. Since the advent of Facebook, Instagram, Plenty Of Fish, and Tinder, the world of friendship and dating has undergone massive changes over the past decade.
While this has enabled more potential connections than ever at one’s fingertips, it also opened the doors to con artists. Unfortunately, with plenty of fish in the sea, the risk of getting catfished increases substantially! Makes sense, right?
Why So Many People Fall For Catfishing Scams
At its core, catfishing works so well because it exploits fundamental aspects of human psychology – trust, attraction, and the desire for human connection. The scammers construct personas that mirror the things that their target is looking for…that could be romance, friendship, or emotional support.
They will often “love bomb” the victim early on in the piece, creating a false sense of intimacy and urgency that helps to fast-track the trust they are aiming to build up in the “relationship”. After they have created the emotional bond, it then becomes more difficult for the victim to question inconsistencies or notice red flags.
Another key psychological tactic is the gradual escalation. The scammers will spend time building up a rapport over weeks, even months. During this grooming phase, they will normalise daily communication routines that match the victim’s timetable and timezone. They make their presence dependable.
By the time they do request money or personal information, the victim is generally already hooked and unaware of the fraud that is already taking place. This slow and steady manipulation is what makes catfishing online so effective, and also why so many smart people still fall for it.
Red Flags: How To Tell If You’re Being Catfished
Catfishing can be very difficult to spot in the early stages. However, there are common red flags that should raise instant suspicion. One obvious sign is that their profile looks and sounds too good to be true. Super attractive photos, very polished backstory and very little interaction with other users.
Conducting a reverse image search using a tool like PimEyes will often reveal that profile pictures have been stolen from models, influencers, or completely unrelated people. Reverse image searches can also reveal that the profile photos have been made using AI generators that create extremely life-like looking fake “photos” that would fool the majority of people.
Another major red flag is the unwillingness to talk on a video call or meet in real life. AI-generated video filters to turn you into someone else aren’t perfect and will often glitch, which can reveal the real person under the filter. This is why catfishers won’t agree to your request for a video call.
Patterns and methods of communication can reveal a lot, too. Scammers will often move the conversation off the dating platform reasonably quickly and get the victims to start using encrypted apps like WhatsApp or Telegram. Sometimes their language can feel a little off, like overly scripted, overly romantic or just not matching the background they claimed to have.
Emotional or financial manipulation is another instant red flag. If someone you’ve never met in real life starts giving you financial advice and tries to get money from you to “invest”, it’s almost always a scam. Also, attempts to gain personal information, sensitive data, intimate photos or verification codes should definitely be recognised as red flags.
If something seems off, it likely is. Trust your instincts. Take your time, verify identities and details where possible. Don’t let anyone rush you into a relationship or pressure you into making any financial investment or decisions. A real and genuine person will be open to verification and won’t pressure you for money or sensitive information.
Why Do People Catfish? Motives Behind Romance Scams
The reasons for catfishing vary substantially, from the devious to the mundane. First of all, there are scammers who seek to steal victims’ money. Drawing on the heartstrings of their targets, they ask for cash to cover for some kind of “emergency”. Alternatively, perpetrators will try to lure matches or friends into lucrative-sounding but ultimately fake investment schemes via romance baiting.
Other catfishers are motivated by revenge or the belief that their victims deserve to be treated contemptuously. They may be a bitter ex, a jealous colleague, or a celebrity-obsessed “fan”. Other offenders don’t know their victims but enjoy trolling others under the cover of anonymity, sometimes even out of boredom.
Finally, culprits might catfish on dating apps because they feel insecure about themselves or are fearful to openly explore their sexual preferences. It is no excuse – being catfished is awful for victims – but catfishing isn’t always done in order to cause harm.
Another growing driver of catfishing scams is identity harvesting and data exploitation. In these cases, the goal of the scammers isn’t immediate financial gain, but rather the slow and steady collection of personal information. They will likely try to extract information such as full names, addresses, workplaces, and sensitive identification documents or intimate photos. They can then use this information for identity theft, account takeovers, or it can be sold on underground marketplaces on the dark web.
There is also a more organised side to catfishing that most people would not be aware of. Sometimes, the individuals running the catfishing scams are part of a large criminal syndicate that operates out of “scam farms”. These types of operations have a large number of people, often working in terrible conditions and under duress, using pre-made scripts that have been designed to maximise emotional manipulation.
How Do Catfishers Operate?
While catfishers angle for various reasons, their modus operandi is generally very similar. At first, it usually involves creating a social media or dating app profile that simply seems too good to be true. Not only is the catfisher typically very handsome, but they also have an exciting and meaningful job, a heartbreaking backstory, do charitable work and are frequently off on thrilling adventures around the world.
They may use their own photos and a fake name on profiles or simply steal the photos of others. Additionally, there are plenty of AI image-generating tools now that will quickly create realistic looking photos of people.
Next, if you friend or match with them, you suddenly have a surprising number of things in common! Their interests just so happen to mirror your own, which can feel exciting and reassuring. But really, you are just getting catfished! To seal the deal, catfishers often engage in a process known as love bombing: showering their victim with affection.
Bypassing their rational defences and gaining their trust, the catfished thus fall for an imaginary person they have never met. Once they have hooked their prey, catfishers will continue feeding them love bait to stoke their infatuation. At the same time, they are mysteriously never able to video-chat or meet in person. Something always gets in the way, such as unexpected work trips, sick relatives or communication malfunctions.
Immediate Steps: What To Do If You Have Been Catfished
Realising that you’ve been catfished sure can hit hard. There can be a mix of embarrassment, disbelief, and anger. The first thing you need to do is stop all communication. Don’t try to confront them or get answers, they will more than likely just try to manipulate you more or simply disappear. Block them on all of the platforms you’ve used to communicate so they have no way to reach you anymore.
Next, take some time to look at all of the information you did share with them. If you did send money, contact your bank immediately. The sooner you act, the more likely that there may be a chance to recover your funds. If you’ve shared personal details like your address, ID or passwords, start locking things down. Create new secure passwords using a strong password generator and enable two-factor authentication where possible. This will help to reduce further risk.
Next, you should contact Cybertrace, and we can assess your case to see if we can help you. It is also highly recommended to report the dating app profile, even though the damage has already been done. This is only a small step for you to take, but it could make a big difference in helping to prevent others from being scammed. In Australia, you can also report it to Scamwatch and the eSafety Commissioner.
Can You Find Out Who A Catfisher Really Is?
In most cases, finding out who a catfisher really is isn’t straightforward. The whole idea of catfishing is to hide behind layers of fake information, stolen or AI generated photos, aliases, burner phone numbers, and dating profile accounts that can be deleted in the blink of an eye. Once they vanish or get called out, the trail goes cold pretty quickly.
In saying that, there are sometimes a few small clues if you know where to look. Reverse image searches can sometimes lead back to the original source of a profile photo, and inconsistencies in their story may hint at where they’re actually based. Most catfishers are following a script, so they are generally very careful not to reveal anything that can identify them.
If the situation involves financial loss or something more serious, it’s definitely time to speak to professionals. Cyber investigation companies and law enforcement have powerful tools that go well beyond what the average person can do themselves. Even then results aren’t guaranteed, but in some cases, the funds can be traced and recovered.
How Cybertrace Unmasks Online Deceivers
Unmasking a catfisher takes more than just a quick Google search; it requires a structured, methodical approach. It also requires technical tools and knowledge of advanced investigative techniques.
At Cybertrace, investigations start by analysing every piece of information the scammer has used: profile images, usernames, email addresses, phone numbers, and the platforms they’ve operated on. Even small details sometimes leave a digital footprint. When cross-referencing this data across multiple platforms, patterns can emerge such as reused photos, matching hosting IP addresses, cloned websites with different branding, or connections to known scam networks.
Just as important is understanding the human side of the scam. By reviewing conversations and patterns of behaviour, it is possible to identify the specific tactics being used – whether it’s romance baiting, investment scams, or long-term social engineering.
While not every case leads to a definite identity, many uncover valuable insights. Whether it’s identifying a scam network, exposing reused assets, or providing evidence that can be passed on to authorities, the goal is always the same: to bring clarity to a confusing situation and help victims regain a sense of control.
Dealing With The Aftermath Of Online Betrayal
Getting your head around what happened after you have been a victim of catfishing isn’t always easy. It’s not just about the time or money; it’s the feeling of being deceived over a long time period that really hurts. Many people will wonder how they didn’t see it coming sooner; however, it’s no wonder these days with how sophisticated these scams have become.
It may help to take a break from social media and dating apps for a while, to help distance yourself from it all and to help clear your head. Filling that space with normal everyday things like getting outdoors, hanging out with friends and getting back into old routines or hobbies can really help. Talking about it to friends or family can also help to make you feel better, and it might help to stop others from falling for the same scam tactics, too.
Most people will get over it eventually, even if it takes a while. The whole experience can make you a lot more cautious in general, which isn’t a bad thing if you don’t take it too far. The key here is not letting that one experience shape how you see everyone else.
There are real people out there, just take your time and trust your instincts…if something just doesn’t feel right, then maybe it isn’t.If you’ve been catfished, you don’t have to deal with it alone. Whether you’ve lost money, shared personal information, or just want answers – Cybertrace can help you understand what’s really going on and what your next steps should be.
Editor’s Note: This article was originally published in October 2022 and has been updated in April 2026 for accuracy and comprehensiveness.
Feel free to tell us your story in the comments section below if you have been the victim of catfishing.
